AMD Ryzen five 3600 vs. Intel Core i5-9600K: 2023 Revisit



Today, we're revisiting the gaming overall performance of two finances CPUs from years beyond: the Ryzen five 3600 and Core i5-9600K. We'll not only examine how they carry out in trendy video games but also benchmark the flagship upgrade alternatives to decide which platform has elderly the nice.

Four years in the past, while we benchmarked each products, the Core i5-9600K turned into on average 4% faster in gaming. However, it regularly lagged in productivity duties as it featured most effective 6 cores and six threads. In comparison, the Ryzen five 3600 boasts 6 cores and 12 threads, making it extra capable. We anticipate this to noticeably benefit its overall performance in modern games.

For checking out, we are using the GeForce RTX 4090 so that you can limit GPU bottlenecks. However, it is really worth noting that by way of modern standards, each the 3600 and 9600K are relatively gradual, that means comparable outcomes can be accomplished with a less costly GPU, consisting of the Radeon RX 6800, particularly if the best settings are slightly decreased.

Both CPUs have been paired with 32GB of dual-rank DDR4-3600 CL14 reminiscence, we have established the modern day BIOS revisions and are going for walks Windows 11. Let's get into it…

Benchmarks

First up, we've Assassin's Creed Mirage, wherein the Core i5-9600K done pretty poorly with pretty weak 1% lows. The sport become nevertheless playable, regardless of being some distance from best, and the revel in using the Ryzen five 3600 become significantly better, with 1% lows of around eighty fps and an average body rate of one hundred fps. Although the 3600 become just 3% quicker in phrases of common body price, it changed into 33% quicker in 1% lows, even at 4K resolution.

Next up, we've got Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty. Here, the 9600K, 3600, and even 3700X all introduced very similar overall performance. Interestingly, while 9600K owners can improve to the 9900K for a 32% overall performance raise, 3600 owners can strengthen to the 5800X3D, resulting in a good sized 71% performance raise.

In Horizon Zero Dawn, the 9600K outperforms the 3600, delivering nine% better average performance, though the 1% lows are plenty the equal. The Core i5 processor performs properly on this older identify.

Moving on to Far Cry 6, we find the 3600 is eleven% quicker than the 9600K on common, with 14% stronger 1% lows. Still, the Core i5 processor controlled to supply notably playable overall performance in this identify. Upgrading to the 9900K gives Intel users a 17% performance improve, while moving from the 3600 to the 5800X3D outcomes in a huge fifty nine% uplift.

The 9600K and 3600 were neck and neck in F1 23, truly turning in identical overall performance. The similar performance among the 3600 and 3700X, each proposing the identical 32MB L3 cache, indicates that cache length is extra vital right here than center rely whilst evaluating 6 to eight cores. The 9900K, with nearly eighty% more L3 cache than the 9600K, explains the 32% overall performance boom at 1080p.

In Assetto Corsa Competizione, the 9600K become eleven% quicker than the 3600 and 18% faster in 1% lows, marking an excellent end result for the Core i5. ACC, being a unmarried-threaded game, showcases the strengths of the 9600K.

Neither the 9600K nor the 3600 are specifically dazzling in Watch Dogs: Legion, a core-heavy, CPU-annoying game. However, the Ryzen 5 processor became 12% faster, averaging sixty five fps at 1080p. Upgrading to the 9900K gives 9600K proprietors a extensive 70% uplift, whilst 3600 proprietors opting for the 5800X3D can expect an astounding 140% overall performance development.

In A Plague Tale: Requiem, the 9600K and 3600 have been again intently matched. The 3600's 1% lows had been worse than those of the 3700X, indicating the benefit of extra cores, however overall, each processors introduced solid performance.

Star Wars Jedi: Survivor become challenging at the 9600K, with longer load instances and great frame drops in comparison to the 3600. Despite the 9600K having 13% better common body rates, the general revel in turned into inferior, with the 3600 imparting 25% higher 1% lows.

In Baldur's Gate 3, the 9600K also suffered from weaker 1% low overall performance. Although its common body rate matched the 3600, the Ryzen five changed into 18% faster in 1% lows. Here once more, upgrading from the 9600K to the 9900K led to an 18% overall performance increase, compared to the eighty four% uplift visible with the 5800X3D for 3600 users.

In Call of Duty: Modern Warfare II, the 9600K become significantly slower than the 3600, averaging simply one hundred forty fps. This made the Ryzen five processor 24% quicker on average and 36% faster in 1% lows, marking a clean win for AMD.

Moving on to Resident Evil four, we find that the 3600, 3700X, and 9600K are all very lightly matched, handing over around eighty fps on common. We additionally see that the 9900K gives just an 18% overall performance improvement over the 9600K, which isn't always a giant upgrade considering the costs concerned. However, the 5800X3D is astonishingly eighty one% faster than the 3600, offering a good sized improve alternative at the same well suited socket.

Despite its age, Shadow of the Tomb Raider stays a middle-heavy, CPU-demanding identify. For checking out, we keep away from the use of the built-in benchmark because it doesn't appropriately constitute the CPU load visible in-recreation. Instead, we test in the village segment, as shown in the pinnacle left corner of the graph.

Here, the 3600 is nine% quicker than the 9600K, a highly minor overall performance advantage. However, the capacity upgrades provide considerably exceptional consequences. The 9900K is 35% faster than the 9600K, a respectable development, however it pales in contrast to the 109% raise the 5800X3D offers over the 3600.

The Core i5 performs properly in The Callisto Protocol, which isn't always a in particular CPU-annoying title. It became eight% faster than the 3600 or even outperformed the 3700X. In this case, the 9600K turned into so green that upgrading to the 9900K simplest yields a ten% overall performance growth. Meanwhile, the 5800X3D become 54% faster than the Core i5.

The Ryzen 5 3600 considerably outperforms the 9600K in Warhammer III, turning in up to fifteen% extra overall performance. The 9900K is only 27% faster than the 9600K, whilst the 5800X3D outpaces the 3600 with the aid of 63%.

Hogwarts Legacy doesn't paintings specifically nicely with any of those older processors, with performance hovering around 40 fps for the 3600, 3700X, and 9600K. Performance is similar common, but once again, the in-socket upgrade gain goes to AMD, as the 9900K tops out at forty six fps, whereas the 5800X3D reaches 60 fps.

In Starfield, the older CPUs don't perform fairly properly, even though it's well worth noting that the 5800X3D isn't always especially effective in this identify either. This data turned into amassed before the latest replace that improves overall performance. Here, the 9600K and 3600 were tied, every reaching 50 fps.

The Core i5-9600K struggles significantly with The Last of Us Part I, particularly with terrible 1% low overall performance, ensuing in a 54% overall performance gain for the 3600 and a 15% increase in average body rate. The common stuttering makes the 9600K improper for this identify.

In Halo Infinite, the 9600K did not stumble upon any overall performance-related issues, except for being slower than the 3600. The Ryzen five part provided an 8% increase to the average body rate.

The 9600K changed into really unstable in Hitman 3, although the general performance turned into first rate with normally clean gameplay. The 3600 became 12% quicker on average, and the 5800X3D offered a more enormous upgrade than the 9900K.

Finally, we've got Spider-Man Remastered, another game in which the Ryzen five 3600 outperforms the 9600K, this time by way of 12%. The upgrade paths additionally want AMD, as the 9900K changed into forty eight% quicker than the 9600K, a extraordinary improvement. However, the 5800X3D surpassed the 3600 by means of 73%.

Performance Summary

We've reviewed the 21 video games tested, and it seems that the Ryzen five 3600 is now outperforming the Core i5-9600K. To affirm this, let's examine the 21-game average, starting with the 1080p facts.

Indeed, the Ryzen 5 3600 has shifted from being 4% slower upon release to being 4% faster now. However, these figures don't absolutely seize the situation. At its release, the 3600 might have been slightly slower on common, however it always added fairly playable frame prices in all games with out stuttering or frame pacing issues.

In comparison, the 9600K nowadays frequently presents a subpar enjoy, marred with the aid of frame stutters and gradual loading times. We have been amazed through the 9600K's sluggishness in loading games and tiers, a hassle we didn't encounter with the Ryzen five 3600. Therefore, the general enjoy turned into substantially better with the Ryzen processor.

Then, there may be the upgrade direction, that is what initiated this collection. Those who invested within the LGA 1151 platform with the 9600K have confined alternatives in the event that they want to hold their motherboard. The 9900K, at the same time as offering a median of 27% extra overall performance, is an steeply-priced CPU. Meanwhile, for a similar funding, the 5800X3D provided a mean performance boom of virtually 70% over the 3600, marking a high-quality upgrade on the identical socket.

Five Years Later

So there you have it, years later, the Ryzen five 3600 has reigned very best, imparting the excellent performance coupled with the quality improve route. These greater less expensive, decrease-end CPUs demonstrate the first rate quality of the AM4 era of Ryzen processors. It's clear now in 2023 that AM4 outperformed LGA 1151, and parts just like the R5 3600 had been a better buy than the 9600K. This became obvious to us four years in the past, when we stated this:

This has been Intel's hassle ever on the grounds that AMD released the AM4 platform entire with a slew of Ryzen processors. Not only have they supported 2, four, 6, eight and now 12-core processors, all on the same socket, however they've controlled to do so throughout three CPU generations. This makes recommending Intel's eighth and 9th era LGA1151 platform difficult in 2019. Short of constructing a high-quit Core i7-9700K or i9-9900K rig, we cannot think of a situation where it makes full feel.

The 9400F is a super example of this limitation. Future improve alternatives are slim, and in a 12 months or two, users will in all likelihood need extra than 6 threads. In a couple of years, second-hand pricing for 8700K, 9700K, and 9900K processors might be horrible, as absolutely everyone invested in the platform will be seeking a quick and easy improve.

With very confined upgrade options and no future support for upcoming generations, recommending the contemporary Intel LGA1151 platform is very tough.

The price of the Ryzen five range was extraordinary, with parts like the 3600 having offered for as low as $ninety five. In assessment, the 9600K by no means dropped beneath $two hundred, though the 9600KF in short reached ~$a hundred seventy five. However, at that point, the 3600 was promoting for just $ninety five, making it the advanced choice and dominating our pleasant fee all-round choose for years.

With simply 6 cores and six threads, along with a relatively small 9 MB L3 cache, the 9600K aged quite poorly. After five years, it is in all likelihood time for an upgrade, and meaning building what is going to be an nearly entirely new PC. The 9900K, averaging handiest 27% faster, is not a sufficient upgrade and is also no longer fee-effective.

The 5800X3D gives about forty% extra performance than the 9900K, making it a considerably better improve and allowing users to extend the lifestyles in their AM4 hardware.

This highlights why platform sturdiness is vital, and it is some thing all PC users have to propose for with AMD, whilst additionally urging Intel to offer better upgrade paths, particularly for lower-end hardware wherein the lack of an actual upgrade direction hurts the most.

The loss of platform dedication is in all likelihood impacting Intel's retail CPU sales, a truth they do not seem to have woken as much as. If AMD can replicate AM4's fulfillment with AM5, it will likely be challenging to advise Intel CPUs inside the coming years. We hope Intel recognizes this and that AMD continues its achievement with AM5. It's unsure which final results is much more likely.

Shopping Shortcuts:

• AMD Ryzen 7 5800X3D on Amazon
• AMD Ryzen 7 7800X3D on Amazon
• AMD Ryzen nine 7900X on Amazon
• AMD Ryzen 9 7950X on Amazon
• AMD Ryzen 9 7950X3D on Amazon
• Intel Core i5-14600K on Amazon
• Intel Core i7-14700K on Amazon
• Intel Core i9-14900K on Amazon

.SubDriveRevBot margin: 30px 0 0px; border-radius: 3px; line-top: 1.Five; font-size: zero.9em; coloration: ssharppfff; background-coloration: ssharpp1d4d84; cursor: pointer; historical past-repeat: no-repeat; background-size: incorporate; historical past-role: proper; .SubDriveRevBot:hover historical past-color: ssharpp245996; transition: zero.4s linear; .SubDriveRevBot a shade: ssharppfff; display: block; width: a hundred%; peak: 100%; .SubDriveRevBot a:hover coloration: ssharppfff; .SubDriveRevBot .Titlerr background: rgba(30, forty one, fifty one, 0.63); padding: 10px 20px 7px; coloration: ssharppfff; letter-spacing: -0.1px; display: block; border-radius: 3px; font-size: 0.9em; .SubDriveRevBot .Commentary font-weight: 500; shade: ssharppf29f26; font-circle of relatives: Roboto; .SubDriveRevBot .Remarknew font-weight: 500; shade: ssharppfea; font-family: Roboto; .SubDriveRevBot .Bulll margin-bottom: 5px !Important; padding: 15px 5px If you experience our content material, please recollect subscribing.

• Ad-unfastened TechSpot revel in even as supporting our paintings
• Our promise: All reader contributions will move closer to investment greater content
• That manner: More tech functions, more benchmarks and analysis